Tim Throckmorton did it again, as he found a trio of stories of major league baseball players with some comical or maybe unfortunate names.

Two of these names and stories are true, but one is made up by Tim himself, can you figure out which one is fake?

They range from Howard "Pooh Pooh" Butt, Johnny Dickshot, and Tony Suck.

Yes two of those names are actual names.

And to top it off, one of them was nicknamed the ugliest man in baseball.

Could Tim Throckmorton stump the studio in this contest, or did the false story get figured out.

We have it all here, and you can play along too.

Classic Memorabilia
Getty Images

More From 92.9 The Ticket